ISO 13849-1 : Standard of Industrial Safety, Performance Level d (PL d)
로봇 자동화 기계안전 안전규격
ISO 13849-1 Advanced Course
Performance Level d (PL d)
Standard of Industrial Safety,
Why do robots and automation systems require PL d?
Learn the design know-how to reduce the probability of dangerous failure to 1 in 10 million.
Module 1. Definition and Meaning of PL d
How safe must it be to be PL d?
Probability of Dangerous Failure per Hour (PFHd)
The PL grade is not just saying "it's safe".
It quantifies the "probability of a dangerous failure occurring during 1 hour of operation".
| PL | PFHd (1/h) | Reliability Level |
|---|---|---|
| PL c | ≥ 10-6 ~ < 3 × 10-6 | 1 in a Million |
| PL d | ≥ 10-7 ~ < 10-6 | 1 in 10 Million |
| PL e | ≥ 10-8 ~ < 10-7 | 1 in 100 Million |
Why is PL d for Robots?
- S2Serious Injury (Severity)
Possibility of fracture, amputation, or death upon collision. - F2Frequent Exposure (Frequency)
Operators frequently approach the robot in automation lines. - P1Possibility of Avoidance
Can be avoided under specific conditions (e.g., slow speed).
Risk Assessment Result ⇒ Minimum PL d Required
Module 2. Recipe to Achieve PL d
The standard design combination to achieve PL d
The Golden Formula for PL d Most common "Category 3" based configuration
- 1
Category 3 Redundancy
Architectural Requirements
No loss of safety function even with a single fault - 2
MTTFd Medium ~ High
Component Reliability
Use certified components with low failure rates (Check B10d) - 3
DCavg Low ~ Medium
Diagnostic Coverage
Cross-check (Feedback) of I/O status
Note: While theoretically Category 2 (Single channel + Test) can achieve PL d, Category 3 (Redundancy) is the industrial standard for robot systems due to control complexity and test cycle limitations.
Module 3. Practical Circuit Design (Category 3)
Example of perfect redundancy from input to output
- INPUTE-Stop Button
- NC 1
- NC 2
★ 2 Contacts (Redundancy)
- LOGICSafety PLC / Relay
- Channel A Processing
- Channel B Processing
Cross Monitoring
- OUTPUTPower Cut-off (MC)
- MC 1
- MC 2
★ Series Connection
EDM (External Device Monitoring) Feedback Loop
Common Mistakes (Failure Causes)
- Single Contact: Connecting E-Stop with only 1 contact (Cat 1 or lower).
- Standard PLC: Handling Safety Functions with standard PLC logic (No diagnostics).
- Fault Masking: Simple series connection of multiple E-Stop buttons prevents fault detection.
Success Points (Check Point)
- EDM Mandatory: Feedback of the output MC's auxiliary contact (NC) to the safety controller.
- CCF Consideration: Separate cabling or shielding to prevent common cause failures.
Module 4. Verification & Software
Manual PL calculation is prone to errors. Verification software is used in the industrial field.
PAScal
Safety calculation software by Pilz
SISTEMA
Free standard tool by IFA (Widely used)