[Machinery Safety Stories] ISO 13849-1 02: Determining PLr
기계안전 안전규격
ISO 13849-1 Series, Part 2 of 5
Determining PLr
Determining the Required Performance Level with the Risk Graph
Before design starts, every safety function needs its required level, PLr.
Three questions, S, F and P, lead to a single value from a to e.
The risk graph: three choices
One PLr per safety function
PLr (Required Performance Level) is the level a safety function must reach to reduce risk adequately. Annex A of ISO 13849-1 (an informative annex) offers a risk graph as an example, and if the product standard for the machine (a type-C standard) sets the PLr, that value applies. This article describes the risk graph of the 2015 edition.
- SSeverity of injurySeverity
- FFrequency and duration of exposureFrequency / Exposure
- PPossibility of avoiding or limiting harmPossibility of avoiding
From the starting point you pick a branch for S, then F, then P, and the point you arrive at is the PLr. If a machine has several safety functions, you run the graph separately for each.
S, F and P one by one
What each choice means
| Symbol | Meaning | On the shop floor |
|---|---|---|
| S1 | Slight injury (normally reversible) | Bruises or cuts that heal after treatment |
| S2 | Serious injury (normally irreversible, including death) | Amputation, crushing, lasting impairment, death |
| F1 | Seldom to less often and/or short exposure | Occasional entry for maintenance |
| F2 | Frequent to continuous and/or long exposure | The operator reaches into the hazard zone every cycle |
| P1 | Possible under specific conditions | The hazard is visible and slow enough to step away from |
| P2 | Scarcely possible | Fast motion or an imperceptible hazard leaves no chance to avoid it |
Annex A of the 2015 edition gives a guide for the F boundary: if the interval between exposures is shorter than 15 minutes, choose F2; if exposures are rarer and the accumulated exposure time is no more than 1/20 of the operating time, choose F1. Where these figures are hard to apply, judge from the exposure frequency set in the risk assessment.
From the start to PLr: the full path table
S1 gives a to c, S2 gives c to e
Choosing S, then F, then P gives eight paths. Each row of the table is one path through the graph.
| S | F | P | PLr |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | F1 | P1 | PL a |
| S1 | F1 | P2 | PL b |
| S1 | F2 | P1 | PL b |
| S1 | F2 | P2 | PL c |
| S2 | F1 | P1 | PL c |
| S2 | F1 | P2 | PL d |
| S2 | F2 | P1 | PL d |
| S2 | F2 | P2 | PL e |
Starting from S1 the PLr is a, b or c; starting from S2 it is c, d or e. If you remember "S1 means a or b", you have missed the path S1, F2, P2, which ends at PL c.
Following three cases
Even in one cell, each safety function gets its own PLr
The cases below carry stated assumptions and are examples only. The real PLr comes from the risk assessment of the actual machine.
-
1
Collaborative robot cell: protective stop when an operator approaches
S2 a body part trapped between the robot and a fixture can cause serious injury. F2 the operator reaches into the robot's workspace every cycle. P1 the robot is slow and its motion is visible, so the operator can step back.
Path S2, F2, P1: PLr d -
2
Door interlock: cut robot drive power when the maintenance door opens
S2 a robot starting while someone is inside can cause serious injury. F1 maintenance entries are a few per day at most and short. P2 a person who has entered can hardly avoid a sudden start.
Path S2, F1, P2: PLr d -
3
Light curtain: detecting entry at a pallet exit
S2 a fast robot striking an operator can cause serious injury. F2 operators pass through every few minutes. P2 the robot is fast and has blind spots, so the hazard is hard to notice.
Path S2, F2, P2: PLr e
If the robot is slowed near that exit so that the operator can see the hazard and step away, P becomes P1 and the PLr is d. If the speed limit is itself a safety function, it needs its own PLr.
Protective stopCobot
S2 · F2 · P1
PLr d
Door interlockDoor
S2 · F1 · P2
PLr d
Light curtainLight curtain
S2 · F2 · P2
PLr e
Judgments that go wrong on site
Errors that push PLr downward are the dangerous ones
"We only go in occasionally, so F1"
Adjustments, clearing jams and recovery from faults add to exposure. Count every task that actually puts a person in the zone, not just normal running.
"Our operators are skilled, so P1"
Skill and operating complexity are supporting factors. Look first at how fast the hazard arises, the space to avoid it and whether it can be seen; if those are unfavourable, choose P2.
"Calling it S1 lowers the PL and the cost"
Choose S by the worst reasonably foreseeable outcome, not the injury you would like to assume. If a pinched finger can end in amputation, it is S2.
"One PLr for every function"
Emergency stop, door interlock and light curtain can each have different S, F and P. A single value for the whole machine over-designs some functions and under-designs others.
When the choice is closePractice
When you hesitate between two options for F or P, record your reasoning and, in practice, lean to the safer (higher) side. Choosing the lower option should come with a reason you can document.
Next · Part 3: Categories in Detail
Once PLr is set, you choose the structure. We compare the input-logic-output structure of Categories B, 1, 2, 3 and 4, dual channels and cross-monitoring, and what a single fault means.