[Machinery Safety Stories] ISO 13849-1 01: Safety Functions and SRP/CS
기계안전 안전규격
ISO 13849-1 Series, Part 1 of 5
Safety Functions and SRP/CS
Safety Function & Safety-Related Part of a Control System
Before talking about PL, Category and MTTFd, there is something to settle first.
Which safety function, and which group of parts is responsible for it?
Why “control reliability”?
Even with guards in place, it is the control system that protects people at the last moment
Machine safety usually calls to mind fences, covers and guards. But equipment that people must enter from time to time, such as a robot cell or a press line, cannot rely on physical protection alone. When the door opens, the robot must stop. When the emergency stop is pressed, drive energy must be cut. When a light curtain is blocked, the hazardous motion must be interrupted. All of this is the job of the control system.
The problem is that control systems fail too. Contacts weld, wires break, sensors stop responding. Nothing happens for years, and then the safety function fails at the exact moment a person is in the danger zone. That is an accident.
ISO 13849-1 makes you ask, quantitatively and at the design stage, “will this safety function still work when it is needed, even if something fails?” That is why the key word is reliability.
What is a safety function?
It is defined by the outcome of the risk assessment, not by the hardware
A safety function is a function the machine must perform to reduce risk, one whose failure immediately increases that risk. Using a safety PLC does not make every function inside it a safety function. A function that used to run on a standard PLC becomes a safety function if the risk assessment says it must.
| Safety function | What it does | Related standard |
|---|---|---|
| Emergency stop | Operated by hand in a hazardous situation to cut drive energy | ISO 13850 |
| Interlocking guard | Stops hazardous motion when the door opens; allows operation only while it is closed | ISO 14119 |
| Protective stop (detection devices) | Stops the machine when a light curtain or laser scanner detects a person | IEC 61496 series |
| Safe torque off (STO) | Prevents the motor drive from producing torque | IEC 61800-5-2 |
| Prevention of unexpected start-up | Keeps the machine from moving again unexpectedly after a stop | ISO 14118 |
A single machine has several safety functions. Even one robot cell has separate emergency stop, door interlock, light curtain and teach-pendant enabling device functions, and a PL is determined for each function separately.
SRP/CS: the group of parts that performs a safety function
One chain from input to output
An SRP/CS (Safety-Related Part of a Control System) is the part of a control system that performs a safety function. If any link breaks, the whole safety function is weakened.
- INPUTInputEmergency stop button, door switch, light curtain
- LOGICLogicSafety relay, safety PLC, safety controller
- OUTPUTOutputContactor (MC), safety valve, drive STO
The wiring and communication between the three blocks are part of the SRP/CS too. The standard calls them interconnecting means, and wiring faults such as open circuits and short circuits must be considered as failure modes.
Example: a door interlock drawn as an SRP/CSDoor Interlock
- Safety function: when the guard door opens, cut power to the robot drives.
- Input: two interlock switches on the door
- Logic: a safety relay that compares the two signals
- Output: two contactors that cut motor power
All four elements together form one SRP/CS, and the PL calculation covers all of them. However good the switches are, if a contactor welds shut, this safety function fails.
Worth rememberingPer Function
An SRP/CS is defined per safety function, not for the whole machine.
It is common for the emergency stop and the door interlock to share the same contactor. In that case the two SRP/CS are considered to share their output part.
PL: the level a safety function achieves
Five levels from a to e, based on the probability of dangerous failure per hour
PL (Performance Level) expresses the ability of an SRP/CS to perform a safety function under foreseeable conditions. The levels are separated by the average probability of a dangerous failure per hour (PFHd).
| PL | PFHd (1/h) |
|---|---|
| PL a | from 10⁻⁵ up to below 10⁻⁴ |
| PL b | from 3×10⁻⁶ up to below 10⁻⁵ |
| PL c | from 10⁻⁶ up to below 3×10⁻⁶ |
| PL d | from 10⁻⁷ up to below 10⁻⁶ ※ typical requirement for industrial robots |
| PL e | from 10⁻⁸ up to below 10⁻⁷ |
PL comes as a pair of values.
- PLr (Required PL): the required level set by the risk assessment. Part 2 covers it with the risk graph.
- PL (achieved): the level the designed SRP/CS actually achieves, determined by Category, MTTFd, DC and CCF. Parts 3 and 4 cover it.
The design goal is simple: achieved PL ≥ PLr.
Where does 13849-1 sit in the design flow?
It starts after the risk assessment
-
1
Risk assessment (ISO 12100)
Identify hazards and estimate the risk.
-
2
Define the safety functions · this article
Decide what must be prevented, and in which situations.
-
3
Determine PLr · Part 2
Set the required level for each safety function.
-
4
Design · Parts 3 and 4
Choose the Category, components, diagnostics and common cause failure measures.
-
5
Calculate PL and verify · Parts 4 and 5
Confirm that the achieved PL is at least PLr.
-
6
Validation · Part 5
Test on the real machine that the safety function works as intended.
Industrial robots have their own safety requirements in the ISO 10218 series, which expresses the required safety-related control performance in terms of the PL and Category of 13849-1. In the 2011 edition the baseline was PL d, Category 3. If your site applies a newer edition, check the requirements of that edition. In Korea the standard is adopted as KS B ISO 13849-1.
Common myths on the shop floor
Keeping these four in mind changes how you inspect
“We used a safety PLC, so we get PL d”
A safety PLC is only the logic block. If the input devices are poorly configured or the output contactors lack diagnostics, the overall PL is pulled down to the weakest part.
“Our machine is fixed at PL c”
PL is set per safety function, not per machine. Within one machine the emergency stop may be PL d while a protective stop on an auxiliary device is PL c.
“Just collect certified components”
A component certificate only vouches for what the component can achieve. The final PL depends on how components are connected and which structure (Category) they are used in, and that responsibility lies with whoever designs the system.
“We calculated it once, so we are done”
Replacing a component, changing wiring or modifying logic means the PL must be checked again. Safety includes confirming that the design assumptions still hold on the floor.
Next · Part 2: Determining PLr
We walk through S, F and P in the risk graph with a collaborative robot cell, a door interlock and a light curtain, and set the required PL for each safety function.