[Economist Review] 01: European industry is doing better than you may think
제조업 지정학
The firms most exposed to China are suffering, but many are adapting. The article questions the habit of treating European industry as a single story of decline, and uses numbers to ask where the pain actually sits.
Deutsche Bank
01The gist of the article
The article opens with Marco Mensink, who runs Cefic, the lobby group for Europe's chemicals companies. His diagnosis is grim: high energy prices and Chinese competition are forcing plant closures and job losses, and further consolidation is unavoidable. Yet on his desk sits a piece of evidence for hope, a cross-section of a cable made by the Chinese firm Orient Cable. The polymer that insulates the wire, however, comes from Borouge International of Austria. Chinese industry leaders keep asking about that European company, because it makes the one part of the cable they cannot yet produce.
The argument is this. Despite fears of widespread deindustrialisation, the damage is for now confined to a handful of sectors, and the firms under threat are adapting to a harsher reality.
What to look for
It helps you tell apart competitiveness by sector and exposure to China, rather than judging the economy of a whole country.
02The harder side: two pressures, energy and China
Energy
- Energy in Europe has long cost more than in America or China.
- Before subsidies, industrial electricity in France and Germany is roughly twice as expensive as in those two countries.
- The wars in Ukraine and Iran have pushed costs higher still.
China
- Industrial policy, innovation and better quality have lifted Chinese output from steel rolls to electric vehicles.
- With domestic demand weak, some overcapacity is finding outlets abroad, and Trump's trade restrictions have made Europe the main target.
- European firms often use local factories and supply chains in China, which limits exports from Europe. China's goods surplus with the EU has more than doubled since 2019, to $420bn.
| Area | What the article reports |
|---|---|
| Cars | Volkswagen said on September 21 that it would step up its restructuring. Five European carmakers have issued profit warnings this year. Chinese rivals now bring good cars to market faster and more cheaply, turning China from a profit engine into a burden. EU car production is 17% below its pre-covid level, and the industry provides 6% of EU jobs. |
| Chemicals | Cefic says plant closures and job losses continue and further consolidation is inevitable. |
| Investment | In a McKinsey study of six industries, Europe received less investment in 2024 than both America and China in three (pharmaceuticals, electronics and chemicals), and led in none. Less cash means a greater risk of falling further behind. |
The European Commission is alarmed too. Its president, Ursula von der Leyen, recently warned that the trade deficit with China is at a tipping point.
03But the pain is concentrated
The article says the pain is highly concentrated by country and by sector. These are the figures cited from Eric Heymann of Deutsche Bank.
- Manufacturing's share of EU gross value addedabout 16% for several years
- Manufacturing's share in Germany and Italyslightly lower
- EU manufacturing employment since early 2023down about 2%, to about 28 million
- Germany's share of that declinefour-fifths
- High-skilled roles (engineers, technicians) over the same periodup 7%
Where jobs rose
Employment in pharmaceuticals, aerospace and electronics has risen since the start of 2023.
Gains from the AI boom
France's Schneider Electric, Germany's Siemens and Italy's Prysmian make gear that keeps data centres running.
Rising defence budgets
Armsmakers such as Germany's Rheinmetall and Italy's Leonardo are boosting production.
04The Chinese threat is concentrated too
Simon Evenett of the Swiss business school IMD argues that the standard story of cheap Chinese goods washing away European firms is overdone. Since 2023, the volume of EU imports from China has grown only a little more than imports of the same goods from elsewhere. Europe is importing more from everywhere, not just from China.
Of Germany's top 100 or so imports from China, 11 saw volume rise by more than 25% and prices fall by more than 10% since 2023 (Evenett's analysis). Most are goods where Chinese and European products compete head-on, such as EVs, furniture and some chemicals.Intermediate goods lower costs
Among the 100 products contributing most to China's export growth since 2023, three-quarters of the growth came from components and intermediate goods such as EV batteries and robotic arms. They threaten makers of similar equipment, but for their European buyers they lower production costs.
European Central Bank study
- Sectors exposed to Chinese intermediate goods (2000–2022)output growth +0.6 pts
- Sectors exposed to Chinese finished goodsoutput growth about −1 pt
05How European firms are adapting
Responding on energy
- In Spain, where plentiful solar power keeps energy prices low, European companies' annual investment doubled in 2021–2025 compared with the previous five years.
- Morgan Stanley judges that European firms are much better prepared for this winter than for 2022, when the Ukraine war cut Russian gas supplies.
- Solvay and K+S have hedged most of their energy consumption for this year.
Services and software
- EU manufacturers exported $460bn of services in 2024, up 21% in two years.
- Denmark's Vestas and Germany's MTU Aero Engines sell maintenance contracts.
- Germany's Siemens moved early, buying several software firms and building software into its hardware.
AI and robots
- Von der Leyen has asked Siemens chairman Jim Hagemann Snabe for a report on how AI might boost productivity.
- Germany has the third-most industrial robots per employee in the world, after Singapore and South Korea. Sweden and Denmark are not far behind.
06The article's conclusion, and another view
The conclusion
Europe has potential, but it should stop mourning old industries and make sure it can harness AI and other new technologies. The gap with America and China on AI is wide, and may grow wider. The article judges that the threat to Europe's industry from energy prices and China is overblown, while the risk of falling further behind on AI probably is not.
A different estimate to set beside it
In a February 2026 report, France's planning agency Le Plan estimated the share of manufacturing output that could be threatened over the medium term, if current trends continue, at about 70% in Germany, about 60% in Italy, about 50% in Spain and 36% in France. The import statistics cited in the article look at changes that have already happened, while this estimate assumes future risk, so the two measure different things and can give different answers to the same question.
Which sector?
First ask whether the goods compete with China head-on in the same market.
Which measure?
Jobs, output, investment and import volumes point to different moments and directions.
Average or mix?
Manufacturing's share can hold steady while the mix of which sectors shrink and grow changes.
What is imported?
Finished goods can be rivals, while intermediate goods can be suppliers that lower costs.
Summary
Whether European industry is in decline depends on where you look. Cars and chemicals are squeezed by energy costs and Chinese competition, while pharmaceuticals, aerospace, electronics and defence are adding jobs and output. Even Chinese imports act differently depending on whether they are finished goods or intermediate goods.
So the article is less a verdict on whether Europe is all right than a prompt to ask which sectors are exposed to China and to energy costs, and where Europe stands in the new race on AI.
Also consulted: Haut-commissariat à la Stratégie et au Plan, The Chinese Steamroller (February 9, 2026)
Figures are as of each source's publication.